NoorSadaNoorSada
BREAKINGPoliticsDeveloping✓ 1 source

This story is currently available in Englisch only — a translation isn't ready yet.

EU leaders leave Dublin split on who negotiates for Europe on Ukraine

Meloni's letter to Costa forced the question onto the agenda; Rome, Warsaw and smaller states back the Council president while the E3 say they cannot be bypassed.

Tempo:

ℹ️ Browser-Stimme · KI-Studiostimme bald verfügbar

PD
Pierre Dubois
· 2 min read
Map: Dublin, Ireland · Photo: NoorSada · Natural Earth

Europe's heads of state and government left an informal European Council in Dublin on Friday still divided over who speaks for the European Union in the Ukraine negotiations, a question Italy's prime minister forced onto the agenda.

Giorgia Meloni wrote to European Council President António Costa a week before the meeting to complain about uncoordinated initiatives and formats, citing informal talks in Miami and a telephone call between Finnish President Alexander Stubb and Vladimir Putin. She said the image of a "fragmented Europe" served only Russia's interests and demanded a decision on "who sits at the negotiating table as representative of the European Union". Costa trimmed the planned session on artificial intelligence and extended the meeting.

The trigger was a statement on X by Trump's son-in-law, who led the US delegation, that Kyiv and Moscow had agreed to widen the next round of talks to include European partners. Putin's assent was the decisive one, and the Kremlin had already cast doubt on it on Friday.

At issue is the E3, the format in which Germany, France and Britain coordinate at leaders' and foreign-minister level. Rome and Warsaw have long objected; they are sometimes folded in as E4 and E5. After the Abu Dhabi round, Rome was allowed to send a representative, and Europe was represented by seven people, because the Council president, the Commission president and the NATO secretary-general also sent envoys. Russia, the United States and Ukraine each had three at the table.

The three governments argue they are Europe's largest and militarily most important states, ready to underwrite a ceasefire and Ukraine's long-term security even without NATO membership, and able to act faster than the club of 27. They decline the debate about a single European voice: the EU, they say, is not a federal state and foreign and security policy is not communitised.

Their weakness is visible. Britain is ruled out because London is no longer in the EU. Chancellor Merz and President Macron are both politically weakened; the French president leaves office in six months, and the chancellor knows a solo trip to Moscow would revive bad historical memories.

Meloni backed Costa in Dublin, arguing that Ukraine negotiations fall within his remit under the EU treaties, which make the Council president the external representative of the member states at his level. Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk took a similar line without naming him: "Only the EU institutions can represent the European Union in negotiations." Luxembourg backed Costa, as did Latvia and Estonia. Estonian Prime Minister Kristen Michal noted that Kaja Kallas is the Union's foreign affairs chief at foreign minister level, and that both answer institutionally to European citizens. Kallas made the same argument on Thursday and Friday, though she meets strong aversion in several member states, partly over professional missteps and partly because she is seen primarily as an Estonian politician on Russia.

In E3 circles it is doubted that Costa has the standing to talk to Putin at eye level. Washington has so far dealt with Commission President von der Leyen.

Sources — how we know this

#Politics○ ...#Diplomacy○ ...