This story is currently available in Englisch only — a translation isn't ready yet.
German expropriation bill would fail in Karlsruhe, legal opinion finds
A report commissioned by Die Linke says the Investitionsschutzgesetz aims only to block Berlin's plan to take over large landlords' housing stock.

Germany's planned Investitionsschutzgesetz would not survive scrutiny by the Bundesverfassungsgericht, a legal opinion commissioned by Die Linke has concluded, because the bill aims only to block expropriations that Article 15 of the Grundgesetz allows the Länder to carry out.
The opinion was written by Isabell Feichtner, a law professor at Würzburg, and two colleagues. Feichtner sat on the Berlin Senate's expert commission on Vergesellschaftung, chaired by former federal justice minister Herta Däubler-Gmelin, which found that Article 15 could be used to take housing from large real-estate companies into common ownership.
"It is quite clear that this is about prevention," Feichtner said of the government's draft. The paper quotes the key-points document: federal law would rule that taking private housing stocks into public ownership through Vergesellschaftung at Land level is no longer possible, so as not to endanger private housing construction.
Feichtner argues that the Bundesverfassungsgericht does not recognise such a blocking effect. Laws that aim, without any substantive regulation of the matter, to exclude the Land legislator from legislating are unconstitutional, the opinion states. She adds that the federal government could only pre-empt Berlin if the law itself transferred private property into common ownership — the opposite of what is intended.
Interior Minister Alexander Dobrindt, who had the key points drawn up with the SPD-led building and justice ministries, said two weeks ago: "We make clear in the key points that expropriation cannot happen arbitrarily." He described a left-wing "Vergesellschaftungsfetisch" as incompatible with the Grundgesetz. Chancellor Friedrich Merz said in July: "We will stop the nationalisation of private housing companies and rented flats." Two months later Die Linke won the Berlin Abgeordnetenhauswahl.
Under the key points, Vergesellschaftung would be allowed only as a "last option", after proof that no other measure could fix the problem, and compensation would be set at market value and paid in cash. Feichtner says that goes beyond the Grundgesetz, which does not fix the level of compensation and requires it to be assessed case by case.
The constitutional lawyer Joachim Wieland told AFP the hurdles "would be so high that expropriations would be effectively excluded". He singled out the requirement that other means be exhausted: "That is precisely not what the Grundgesetz provides for."
The doubts run into the coalition. Justice Minister Stefanie Hubig, of the SPD, pointed to Article 15: "It is not that simple to say: it is forbidden." Juso chief Philipp Türmer said: "I consider it unconstitutional." Die Linke has said it will file suit in Karlsruhe.
Sources — how we know this
- PrimaryTagesschau