NoorSadaNoorSada
BREAKINGEditorialDeveloping✓ 1 source

This story is currently available in Englisch only — a translation isn't ready yet.

Police Scotland complaints backlog eroding trust, watchdog chief warns

PIRC commissioner Laura Paton says only 48% of complaints reviewed in 2025/26 were reasonably handled, with 337 investigations unallocated last month

Tempo:

EH
Eleanor Hughes
· 2 min read
A stone police station with blue-trimmed gables and blue door under cloudy sky · Symbolbild · Photo: AlixChaytor / CC BY-SA 4.0

Scotland's police watchdog has warned that record demand and a growing backlog of complaints are damaging public confidence in Police Scotland, with 337 investigations still unallocated as of last month.

Laura Paton, the Police Investigations and Review Commissioner, said an "incredible" record level of demand was risking her organisation's ability to deliver justice on behalf of communities, and that there is "a limit to what we alone can achieve." In her first media interview since being appointed last year as commissioner, she said growing workload and resource constraints meant PIRC may not deliver the service the public expects, and that without additional backing its increasingly complex investigations would only take longer.

Of the complaints PIRC reviewed across 2025/26, only 48 per cent were deemed to have been reasonably handled. "That really is a huge concern," Ms Paton said, adding that years back, PIRC "would have been up at the 60 to 70 per cent figure" and that it was really disappointing that complainers were not getting the service that PIRC would expect them to get.

PIRC received 295 applications in 2025/26 for a complaint handling review, a 29 per cent increase on the previous year.

The Scottish Police Authority's complaints and conduct committee annual report recorded 6,637 complaints from members of the public to Police Scotland in 2024/25, down 653 from 2023/24, but with increases in certain categories of allegation: excessive force (up 23.3 per cent), corrupt practice (11.1 per cent) and neglect of duty (8.1 per cent).

The Scottish Crime and Justice Survey found only 45 per cent of adults believed police in their local area were doing an 'excellent' or 'good' job in 2024/25, against 61 per cent when the question was first asked in 2012/13. Of those who had an interaction with the police, only 60 per cent were satisfied with how officers handled the matter, down from 70 per cent in 2018/19.

Police Scotland has temporarily reallocated some professional standards department resources to help non-criminal complaint handling teams. Ms Paton said that "every single one of those complaints is a person" who is already dissatisfied with the police service they've received, and they then become dissatisfied with the complaint handling response they've received, adding that she thought they lost faith during that process.

Of 231 recommendations PIRC made to the force in 2025/26, 140 remain outstanding. "It's absolutely a concern that there are so many outstanding recommendations," she said, adding that the expectation is that recommendations are implemented within two months.

PIRC also initiated 41 investigations into deaths involving policing in 2025/26, a 128 per cent increase from the 18 it commenced in 2024/25, and is dealing with its highest ever caseload of simultaneous death investigations. Ms Paton said there is "no sign of it abating."

She also raised a complaint PIRC recently reviewed involving a teenage girl whose clothing was forcibly removed while in police custody, saying nobody asked her about her experience and that custody policies should be more child-focused.

Sources — how we know this

#Judiciary○ ...