This story is currently available in Englisch only — a translation isn't ready yet.
Scotland's police watchdog warns record caseload is delaying investigations
Police Investigations and Review Commissioner Laura Paton says 191 investigations, including 49 deaths, are open as demand outgrows the watchdog's resources
ℹ️ Browser-Stimme · KI-Studiostimme bald verfügbar
Scotland's police watchdog is managing 191 investigations, including 49 deaths, and has warned that a record caseload is lengthening the time it takes to complete them.
Laura Paton, the Police Investigations and Review Commissioner (Pirc), said the level of demand was jeopardising her organisation's ability to help deliver justice on behalf of communities. In Pirc's annual report, covering the 12 months to 31 March, the commissioner recorded 41 death investigations begun during the year — a 128% increase from 18 in the 2024-25 period. Seven of those concerned domestic abuse-related homicides and suicides.
The organisation said this year brought its highest ever number of simultaneous death investigations. Paton described the rise in demand as "beyond our control" and said "there is a limit to what we alone can achieve".
Pirc has carried out a strategic review assessing demand against resources and setting a new future direction, but Paton said wider action was now needed given a "sustained increase in demand". She said: "a further deterioration in the timeliness of our investigations is inevitable" without external intervention such as a reduction in demand, additional funding or a delay to the expansion of Pirc's statutory functions.
She added that Pirc would not be able to deliver the service the public rightly expects, affecting bereaved families and complainers as well as confidence in police accountability and policing itself.
The commissioner also said she expected more members of the public to seek help from Pirc as Police Scotland works through a significant backlog of police complaints, and noted delays in Police Scotland's implementation of recommendations arising from Pirc reviews. Police Scotland and the Scottish government have been approached for comment.
Sources — how we know this
- PrimaryBBC Scotland