NoorSadaNoorSada
BREAKINGEconomy✓ 1 source

This story is currently available in Englisch only — a translation isn't ready yet.

Ukraine's Supreme Court: a change of heat supplier does not give the right to raise tariffs

The Grand Chamber of the Supreme Court ruled that consumers pay according to the tariffs in effect as of 24 February 2022, and departed from the position of the Cassation Commercial Court.

Tempo:

ℹ️ Browser-Stimme · KI-Studiostimme bald verfügbar

AK
Anna Kuznetsova
· 2 min read
Klovskyi Palace in Kyiv, the seat of Ukraine's Supreme Court · Photo: Wadco2 / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 3.0)

The Grand Chamber of the Supreme Court of Ukraine has ruled that a change of supplier of thermal energy and hot water during martial law cannot be grounds for applying to consumers a tariff higher than the one applied by the previous supplier before 24 February 2022. This is reported on the court's website.

The court resolved divergences in the practice of the cassation instances. The moratorium on raising tariffs for thermal energy and for services supplying thermal energy and hot water is established by Article 1 of law No. 2479-IX of 29 July 2022 "On the specifics of regulating relations on the natural gas market and in the sphere of heat supply during martial law and the subsequent restoration of their functioning" in the version in force at the time the disputed legal relations arose. It protects consumers regardless of who sets the tariffs and who provides the services.

The case was considered on the claim of a Kremenchuk resident against Poltavateploenergo for a recalculation of the cost of thermal energy and hot water supply. After the Kremenchuk CHPP equipment was destroyed by missile strikes, the service supplier changed: from November 2022 the new supplier began charging the plaintiff at tariffs higher than those applied to him as of 24 February 2022.

The court of first instance dismissed the claim. The appellate court overturned that decision and ordered the company to recalculate the charges for the 2022-2023 heating season, the 2023 inter-heating period and the 2023-2024 season, taking into account the tariffs in effect for the plaintiff as of 24 February 2022.

In its cassation appeal the company argued that it applies uniform tariffs for consumers of the region set by the Poltava Regional Council at the level of those in effect for the company itself as of 24 February 2022, and that it is not the legal successor of Kremenchuk CHPP LLC.

The panel of the Cassation Civil Court referred the case to the Grand Chamber because of opposing approaches in practice. The Cassation Commercial Court, in its ruling of 26 September 2024 in case No. 917/1389/23, concluded that Article 1 of law No. 2479-IX does not apply to these legal relations, since the supplier is not authorized to set or change tariffs. The Cassation Civil Court, in a number of cases, in particular in its ruling of 28 January 2026 in case No. 524/2748/24, indicated that applying the regional council's tariffs to consumers in the left-bank part of Kremenchuk violates their rights.

The Grand Chamber took into account that a consumer cannot independently choose a supplier of centralized heat supply and hot water supply services. "He should not bear additional costs as a result of decisions by authorities or a change of supplier," the statement says. The company's lack of authority to change tariffs does not release it from complying with the moratorium, since it is the one that charges the consumer.

The court also noted that, by introducing the moratorium, the state, under Articles 2 and 3 of law No. 2479-IX, undertook to compensate suppliers from the state budget for the difference in tariffs and the costs caused by hostilities. The Grand Chamber upheld the conclusion of the Cassation Civil Court and departed from the conclusion of the Cassation Commercial Court set out in the ruling of 26 September 2024; it dismissed the company's cassation appeal and left the appellate decision unchanged.

Sources — how we know this

#Economy○ ...#Law○ ...