This story is currently available in anglais only — a translation isn't ready yet.
Ceylan Finds Second Article of Mecca Agreement Harsher Than NATO's Article 5
Retired Ambassador Mehmet Fatih Ceylan said the agreement signed by Türkiye, Pakistan and Saudi Arabia contains an 'immediate assistance' provision; the intersection of the two mechanisms is Türkiye.

Retired Ambassador Mehmet Fatih Ceylan said the second article of the Mecca Agreement signed between Türkiye, Pakistan and Saudi Arabia is harsher than the wording in NATO's Article 5. In the interview in which he answered Cumhuriyet's questions, Ceylan pointed to the second article as the "backbone" of the agreement.
Ceylan relayed the text of the article as follows: in the event that one of the parties is subjected to an armed attack or military aggression by a country or group of countries, the others "will immediately rush to its aid," he said. The second part of the article contains the statement, "The nature and scope of the assistance will be assessed within the framework of available means."
Asked whether the distinction between "armed attack or military aggression" differentiates between a country's official army and unofficial armed forces, Ceylan replied, "You can interpret it that way." According to him, if Iran attacks a facility in Saudi Arabia, the three countries need to come together to give effect to the second article.
On the NATO side, the mechanism works differently. Assessing Iran's statement that it would also target Europe in a possible attack, Ceylan noted that an attack on a NATO member country falls within the alliance's founding treaty: "At best it has the potential to trigger Article 4; at worst, Article 5." He described as "high" the likelihood that, if Iran attacks a NATO member, the targeted country would bring the matter to NATO to invoke Article 5.
According to Ceylan, the intersection of the two mechanisms is Türkiye: "The intersection of both is Türkiye." He said planning on security matters is done by considering the worst-case scenario, and that defense agreements are designed accordingly.
Arguing that the US, through the Mecca Agreement, is preparing the ground to share the security burden with regional countries by reducing its military presence in the Middle East, Ceylan noted that Washington cannot easily withdraw from the region because of Israel. Ceylan also added that after the US midterm elections the likelihood that no new attack is carried out against Iran is higher, and that phone traffic between Erdoğan and Trump has increased.
Sources — how we know this
- PrimaryCumhuriyet Gazetesi