This story is currently available in anglais only — a translation isn't ready yet.
Judges call Trump's IRS settlement a 'fraud against the court'
Judge Kathleen Williams called a Justice Department-backed settlement of Trump's $10bn IRS suit a 'fraud against the court'; a New York judge separately blocked $20m in ad spending.

A federal judge in Florida found that a Justice Department-backed settlement of Donald Trump's $10bn lawsuit against the Internal Revenue Service was "premised on deception" and a "fraud against the court", one of a series of rulings that have rejected the president's financial and political schemes.
Judge Kathleen Williams ruled in mid-July that the deal — which would have set up a $1.8bn fund to pay alleged victims of political persecutions under Joe Biden and given Trump immunity from IRS audits before May 2026 — was pursued "for an improper purpose". The plaintiffs, she wrote, had acted in bad faith by "collusively filing a lawsuit" with claims subject to multiple dispositive defenses, solely to provide cover for a collusive settlement, and the case was part of a "pattern of misusing the courts to serve political purposes".
The Justice Department dropped the fund after the ruling and political blowback in Congress. A provision granting Trump, his family and the Trump Organization immunity from IRS investigations and prosecutions of past tax matters remains in effect, despite criticism from Democratic senators including Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts.
Trump's lawyers said in late July they would appeal the Williams order. In late September, the federal appeals court for the 11th circuit denied a request by two Trump lawyers, Alejandro Brito and Daniel Epstein, to pause sanctions imposed over their handling of the $10bn suit, ruling they had not demonstrated they would succeed in challenging the finding that they acted in bad faith.
In New York, district judge Jennifer Rochon issued two restraining orders in October stopping the use of public funds for campaign-style advertising, after Campaign Legal Center Action, representing Common Cause, along with Public Integrity Project Action and Democracy Forward sued. In her second emergency order on 30 October, Rochon ruled that three ads could no longer run using government funds on Instagram and two other sites because they were "purely partisan". Trump had channelled $20m of public funds into ads touting his administration's achievements, which were widely attacked as campaign ads and propaganda.
The suits were brought by nonpartisan groups including Democracy Forward and the Campaign Legal Center. In July, Democracy Forward and a coalition of 35 ex-judges, including the retired federal appeals court judge J Michael Luttig, sued to kill the $1.8bn fund.
Stacey Young, a former Justice Department lawyer who set up Justice Connection, said the department's leadership "believes it has one chief client: President Trump". Luttig said the courts had begun to strike down "countless schemes of blatant and shameless venality and corruption" in the forms of self-enrichment, bribery, and extortion.
Sources — how we know this
- PrimaryThe Guardian — US news