This story is currently available in anglais only — a translation isn't ready yet.
Konya appellate court overturns 20-installment sentence in MESEM student's death
The 2nd Criminal Chamber of the Konya Regional Court of Justice found an incomplete investigation in the case of Muhammed Salih Gövdetaşan, who died after being crushed between a pickup truck and a wall.

According to bianet, the 2nd Criminal Chamber of the Konya Regional Court of Justice (BAM) overturned the ruling in the case concerning the death of Muhammed Salih Gövdetaşan, a Vocational Education Center (MESEM) student, who was crushed between a pickup truck and a wall at the auto repair shop where he worked. With the chamber's unanimous ruling dated 5 November 2024, the file was sent back to the Konya 15th Criminal Court of First Instance for retrial. The decision is final under Article 286/1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
The appellate court stated that the local court's ruling did not sufficiently clarify how the incident occurred and the degree of fault of the defendants. The chamber requested an on-site inspection accompanied by an occupational safety expert and the preparation of a new report; it noted that if the new report contradicts the previous reports, the contradictions must be resolved. It thus concluded that the local court had based its verdict on an incomplete investigation.
The Konya 15th Criminal Court of First Instance had initially sentenced the journeyman who was driving the vehicle, Hasan Büyükaşcı, to 2 years 6 months in prison, reduced the sentence to 2 years 1 month with a reduction, and then converted it into a judicial fine of 76,000 TL. The court also ordered that the fine be paid in 20 installments, and issued a decision to defer the announcement of the verdict for workplace owner Mehmet Yelmez. The appellate court noted that, taking into account the manner in which the offense was committed, the gravity of the fault and the nature of the resulting harm, the sentences should be determined by departing from the lower limit. The chamber stated that the conditions for converting the prison sentence into a fine were not met in the case of Büyükaşcı.
Muhammed Salih's father, Savaş Gövdetaşan, said they considered the reversal decision significant and that they would continue to follow the case: "Until justice is secured for my son," he said, adding that they would continue the struggle to shed light on what happened to his son and for those responsible to receive the punishment they deserve, that they would also follow this decision, and that they would recognize no obstacles.
Gövdetaşan recounted that after he shared footage of the moment of his son's death at the repair shop where he worked on his social media accounts, an investigation was launched against him and he was summoned to the police station to give a statement. According to him, he was verbally told of allegations of violation of privacy, threat and insult; he was not given a document showing the scope and legal basis of the investigation.
The family's objection to the camera recordings continues. The family's lawyer, Ömer Faruk Seleş, had said that camera and audio recordings were not collected, that witnesses were not adequately heard, and that the allegation of intent was not investigated. The appellate court's new decision makes it mandatory to re-examine how the incident occurred and the degree of fault; whether the allegation of intent previously raised by the family will be addressed in the retrial will become clear once the trial effectively begins.
Sources — how we know this
- PrimaryBianet