NoorSadaNoorSada
Geopolitics

This story is currently available in anglais only — a translation isn't ready yet.

Kushner promised Europe a seat. Ushakov is pricing the chair.

Two American envoys told the world Europe would be at the next round. A Kremlin aide then explained, in the passive voice, that nobody had asked Moscow.

Vitesse:

ℹ️ Lecture par le navigateur · voix studio IA bientôt

Natasha Volkov
· 4 min read
Image d'illustration · Photo: Wee Hong / CC BY-SA 4.0 (Wikimedia Commons)

The Kremlin did not retract a promise on Monday. It disclosed that nobody in the room had the standing to make one.

Two American envoys, Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner, flew to Moscow, met Vladimir Putin, and told the world afterwards that Europe would be at the next round of Ukraine talks. On Monday, Yury Ushakov, a senior Kremlin aide, told reporters that what is currently being discussed is a trilateral format, that the date has not been agreed, and that expansion — 'some people are talking about it' — 'has not been agreed with us.'

Read that last clause twice. Not 'we refuse.' Not 'we object.' It has not been agreed with us. The passive voice is doing the work of a veto while leaving the veto unowned. It is the sentence of an institution that intends to keep the American envoys' optimism on the record and the Europeans' absence on the ground, and to be able to say later that it never lied to anyone.

Ushakov then named his price: Russia's consent depends on 'a clear signal from the Europeans about what they want and what constructive, substantive contribution they can make.' Treat that as a procurement request rather than a diplomatic courtesy. Moscow is not asking Europe to attend. It is asking Europe to arrive with a bill of lading — what you will pay, what you will monitor, what you will lift and when. Presence is the reward for the contribution, not a precondition for talks. He added that a round or more of trilateral talks may be needed first, which is the sequencing that actually matters. Every trilateral round held before Europe enters is a round in which the baseline gets set without Europe in the room.

Europe's answer to 'who speaks for you' arrived on Friday from Dublin. António Costa, chairing the European Council, announced that the European team would be national security advisers from France, Germany, Italy, Poland and Britain, plus representatives of the Commission and the Council. Five capitals and two institutions: a construction designed to satisfy every internal claimant and to answer no external question. The foreign ministers of Spain and Lithuania objected on arrival.

And the bloc's own chief diplomat was not on the list. Kaja Kallas, asked about her absence, told reporters to 'take out the treaties and read the treaties,' noted that she is the official who deals with security and foreign policy under them, and said she is 'ready to do this job as well.' She is right about the text and irrelevant to the outcome, which is the worst position in Brussels. Ushakov's demand for a single clear signal now meets a continent whose treaty architecture and whose political settlement point at different people. Moscow does not have to exploit that. It only has to wait, and waiting costs it nothing while the trilateral rounds continue.

Then there is the money, which is where the rostrum and the budget part company. Kushner's account of the progress rests on three pillars: security guarantees for Ukraine, its membership in the European Union, and a plan to rebuild its economy. Every one of those is an invoice addressed to European treasuries. He is careful to add that NATO 'will remain a critical pillar of European security.' Now list what Russia concedes inside the same three pillars. Nothing. Europe is being asked to underwrite a settlement whose terms are being drafted in a format it is not in. That is not a diplomatic slight. It is a financing structure, and a good one — for everyone except the payer.

The ground is not waiting for the seating plan. On Monday, Kyiv's mayor reported preliminary indications that the North and South bridges across the Dnipro had been hit; Ukraine struck the Crimea Bridge again and targeted oil refineries, in what Russian defence ministry data indicated was the largest overnight drone attack on Russia since 2022. Zelenskyy called the day's online session with the American envoys and European representatives 'not easy,' and said the participants would meet in Berlin with the Coalition of the Willing. Escalation before a format is fixed is not irrationality. It is how each side improves the baseline that the format will inherit.

The institutional habit at work is older than any of the officials in it: in European settlements, the seating plan has usually turned out to be the substance, and whoever fixes the seating fixes what is negotiable. Which is why the interesting question is not whether Europe deserves a chair. It is whether Moscow can extract a European contribution before conceding the chair, and whether Europe can produce a single number before it produces a single negotiator.

Last week I argued that the swap being floated around Donbas and NATO would die in ratification — that the promise outran the institutions required to deliver it. Same disease, different organ. The Moscow promise outran the authority of the men who made it. A signed communiqué would have been checkable. A press availability is not.

Two developments would move me off this. A date for a four-party round, confirmed by Moscow rather than announced by Washington. Or a European team that arrives with one written page — a contribution figure and a monitoring offer — instead of a mandate dispute. Until then the arithmetic is simple: the next round will be trilateral, it will happen without Europe, and the war will keep setting the agenda that the talks are supposed to be about.