NoorSadaNoorSada
BREAKINGEditorialDeveloping✓ 1 source

This story is currently available in anglais only — a translation isn't ready yet.

NI Audit Office finds £5m wasted on weakly drafted vehicle testing contract

Auditor General Dorinnia Carville says the Driver and Vehicle Agency deal contributed to long delays in improving MOT centres

Vitesse:

ℹ️ Lecture par le navigateur · voix studio IA bientôt

EH
Eleanor Hughes
· 2 min read
A car drives through a gated testing site with a blue building · Image d'illustration · Photo: Kenneth Allen / CC BY-SA 2.0

A weakly drafted contract meant the Driver and Vehicle Agency (DVA) took years to get rid of a company that was failing to deliver an upgrade of its vehicle testing centres, the Northern Ireland Audit Office (NIAO) has found.

The botched deal wasted £5m and has contributed to long delays in improving the MOT centres. The company had fallen six weeks behind schedule within just six months of winning the contract in 2019.

After a protracted legal process it was eventually paid £1.5m to go away, described as "a significant fruitless expenditure". A further £3.6m was spent on the project.

The report does not name the company; it has previously been identified as Worldwide Environmental Products Inc. (WEP Inc).

By February 2022 the DVA had issued two formal warnings to WEP Inc for poor performance and moved to terminate the contract. The company won a High Court challenge when a judge ruled the contract did not specify clear dates for implementing key systems. The deal was terminated ahead of a second court case.

Auditor General Dorinnia Carville said the report showed "a significant waste of public money" and that weaknesses in the contractual arrangements "made it more difficult to bring the contract to a timely conclusion".

The report also identifies weaknesses in the procurement process. WEP Inc's successful tender was priced at £10.8m, 53% lower than the only other compliant bid and 40% below the DVA's business case estimate. The DVA followed the correct procurement processes and further checks were undertaken, but these did not provide sufficient assurance the solution could be delivered at the price quoted.

Carville said the DVA and Stormont's Central Procurement Directorate had identified lessons and there is evidence these have been acted upon, adding it was vital that learning is shared beyond the two organisations.

A replacement contract for the testing centres was awarded in March this year at a value of £46m, with completion expected in mid-2029. The report notes direct comparison with the original £10.8m bid is difficult because of changes in project scope, implementation assumptions and contract lifespan.

A spokesperson for the Department for Infrastructure said: "The Department welcomes the publication of the NIAO Report and is considering the findings."

Sources — how we know this

#Politics○ ...