NoorSadaNoorSada
BREAKINGPoliticsDeveloping✓ 1 source

This story is currently available in англійська only — a translation isn't ready yet.

Electoral reform commission pencilled in for launch before Christmas

Plans drawn up by the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government, with No 10 closely involved, as Labour MPs split over proportional representation

Швидкість:

EH
Eleanor Hughes
· 3 min read
House of Commons Chamber in London · Photo: UK Parliament / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 3.0)

Plans for a national commission on electoral reform are being drawn up inside the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government, with a launch pencilled in for before Christmas, though it may be pushed into the new year. No 10 has so far been closely involved, while the department is also focused on other priorities, including delivering the pledge to offer all those who need it a route out of rough sleeping.

Andy Burnham announced a national commission on electoral reform in September. He is a convert to replacing first-past-the-post (FPTP) with proportional representation: in 2021 he wrote on X that he had "come round" to the idea and now supports changing all UK elections to a PR system. Options a commission could consider include the Single Transferable Vote, the Additional Member System, Proportional List systems and variants of each.

Labour MPs, ministers included, are far from united on moving away from FPTP, the system under which Labour won its landslide majority in 2024. Louise Haigh, Deputy PM and Burnham's close ally, has concerns about shifting to PR. The commission will fall under the jurisdiction of Secretary of State for Housing Angela Rayner, whose long-held views against PR make her position awkward: in 2022 she said she was a "first-past-the-post girl" who was "yet to be convinced by PR", telling The News Agents podcast that it could allow extremist parties such as the British National Party (BNP) to win House of Commons seats. Her concern at the time centred on the importance of the constituency link, and some say she is now coming around to the idea.

John Healey, now Chancellor, campaigned against electoral reform in the 2011 referendum on the alternative vote, describing it as "perverse". Ed Miliband, now Foreign Secretary, was a strong proponent of electoral reform during that campaign. Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy has previously said she favours proportional representation but would like every constituency to have an MP.

Several Labour MPs who recently became ministers signed, as backbenchers, an amendment to the Representation of the People Bill calling for a national commission, among them now-Energy Secretary Miatta Fahnbulleh, communities minister Florence Eshalomi and the Prime Minister's parliamentary private secretary Jo Platt. It was ruled out of scope in September.

"It is complete navel-gazing," one Labour MP said, adding that prioritising electoral reform over improving public services and our economy was a distraction from the real problems facing this country. Many backbench MPs fear they would lose out under PR, and speculation about an early election next year has heightened those concerns.

The government wants the commission to be as non-partisan as possible, with cross-party buy-in and commissioners who are not party-affiliated and cannot be seen to have favoured a particular voting system in the past. It is hunting for a chair likely to be someone akin to Alan Milburn, who is leading the review into the Neets crisis. Elections expert professor John Curtice, one name floated, said he had "not heard a dicky bird".

Ministers are understood to be looking closely at a 2025 blueprint for a national commission published by the All-Party Parliamentary Group for Fair Elections, and are keen that the importance of maintaining some sort of constituency link is written into the terms of reference.

Henry Tufnell, the Labour MP for Mid and South Pembrokeshire, said his experience of PR in Wales had made him more opposed to changing Westminster's voting system. He said he saw on the doorstep ahead of the Welsh elections how "democratic accountability can be lost under proportional representation" and the broken link between the electorate and the representative. "We should think very carefully about introducing any legislation nationally on electoral reform," he said.

Sources — how we know this

#Politics○ ...#Elections○ ...