NoorSadaNoorSada
BREAKINGJudiciaryDeveloping✓ 1 source

This story is currently available in англійська only — a translation isn't ready yet.

Istanbul 14th Heavy Penal Court rejects Kavala's release appeal

Despite the ECtHR Grand Chamber's violation ruling dated 25 August 2026, the court turned down the retrial request on the grounds that "domestic legal remedies have not been exhausted."

Швидкість:

MY
Mehmet Yılmaz
· 2 min read
Curved glass courthouse behind a road with cars under partly cloudy sky · Photo: CeeGee / CC BY-SA 4.0

The Istanbul 14th Heavy Penal Court on 13 November 2026 rejected the objection filed against the request for a retrial of Osman Kavala's case and for his release. In its ruling numbered 2026/286 D.İş, the court found the additional ruling of the Istanbul 13th Heavy Penal Court dated 13 October 2026 to be in accordance with procedure and law.

The grounds for the rejection rest on the rule of "exhaustion of domestic legal remedies," which is considered a precondition for applying to the European Court of Human Rights. Citing the ECtHR's Hasan Uzun v. Turkey judgment (Application No: 10755/13, 30/04/2013), the ruling stated that Kavala had applied to the ECtHR without exhausting domestic legal remedies.

The Istanbul 13th Heavy Penal Court had also rejected the retrial and release request in the file numbered 2021/178 (case) and 2022/178 (decision) on the same grounds in its additional ruling dated 13 October 2026. The court argued that accepting a retrial request without the exhaustion of domestic legal remedies would mean that "it would constitute an interference with a sovereign state's independent exercise of its judicial authority, exceeding the jurisdiction of an international court," and included the statement that "the ECtHR is not a court of appeal."

At the center of the debate is the ECtHR Grand Chamber's judgment of 25 August 2026 in Kavala v. Turkey (No. 2), Application No: 2170/24. The Grand Chamber ruled that the conviction handed down against Kavala was contrary to the European Convention on Human Rights and that Article 18 had been violated; it stated that the conviction was a "flagrant denial of justice" and had no legal basis whatsoever.

In an application dated 8 September 2026, Kavala had requested a retrial, a suspension of the execution of the sentence and his immediate release.

Kavala had been sentenced to "aggravated life imprisonment" on 25 April 2022 by a ruling of the Istanbul 13th Heavy Penal Court numbered 2021/178 (case) and 2022/178 (decision) under Article 312 of the Turkish Penal Code. His appeal was rejected on the merits by a decision of the 3rd Criminal Chamber of the Istanbul Regional Court of Justice dated 28 December 2022, and the 3rd Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation upheld the sentence on 28 September 2023.

Bianet reported that Kavala applied to the Constitutional Court on 9 June 2022 and 25 July 2023, and that the Constitutional Court has not ruled on these applications.

Sources — how we know this

  • PrimaryBianet
#Judiciary○ ...