NoorSadaNoorSada
BREAKINGEconomyDeveloping✓ 1 source

This story is currently available in англійська only — a translation isn't ready yet.

Ifo study puts German utilities' crisis windfall at up to 20.5 billion euros

Munich researchers say gas costs alone cannot explain the 2022 price spikes; the cartel office says generators' market power has grown.

Швидкість:

PD
Pierre Dubois
· 2 min read
The Ifo Institute for Economic Research building in Munich, Germany · Photo: Carl Steinbeißer / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 3.0)

Germany's five largest electricity generators earned additional revenues of 10.7 billion to 20.5 billion euros between September 2021 and December 2022, a study published Monday by the Munich-based Ifo Institute finds, concluding that higher gas costs alone cannot explain the price spikes of the energy crisis.

RWE, LEAG, EnBW, Uniper and Vattenfall together hold around 56 percent of conventional power plant capacity in Germany, the researchers note, while renewables now cover almost 61 percent of electricity demand on average. Under the merit-order principle the most expensive plant still needed sets the price for every supplier, and gas plants set it in many hours.

Ifo simulated two markets: one of perfect competition, in which every operator bids at marginal cost, and one in which the five largest producers recognise that their bids move the price and hold back part of their capacity. Until September 2021 the competitive simulation tracked observed prices closely. From the start of the gas crisis, observed prices ran well above it, especially in summer 2022, when spikes exceeded 600 euros per megawatt hour. The average gap was around 45 euros per megawatt hour, and still around 20 euros under very cautious assumptions. The strategic-behaviour simulation deviated by about four euros.

"Interpreting the results as a one-off episode falls short," the Ifo researchers wrote, arguing that a concentrated ownership structure and the pricing power it produces are permanently built into the market.

The institute criticised the first auction round for gas-fired capacity: 99 percent of the 5.16 gigawatts on offer went to RWE and LEAG, because awards per bidder were not capped at 10 percent of the auction volume as the Bundeskartellamt had proposed.

Bundeskartellamt president Andreas Mundt said the authority's investigations had shown for years that individual generators hold considerable market power, and that it has recently grown. He added that "not every high electricity price is the result of antitrust abuse", and that a review of price spikes at the end of 2024 found no evidence of abusive conduct.

Ifo called for faster build-out of renewables and above all battery storage, to cut the hours in which conventional plants are needed, and for mandatory publication of bids for each individual plant on the day-ahead market.

Uniper rejected the findings, saying it is subject to comprehensive supervision and complies with competition and energy law, and that 2021 and 2022 were a "historic exceptional situation".

Sources — how we know this

#Economy○ ...#Energy○ ...
⚡
Autonomous PickMarketplace

Energy Portfolio

Check your broker for the latest on energy stocks.

View Now →