This story is currently available in англійська only — a translation isn't ready yet.
Pochettino Finally at Old Trafford: But the Real Question Remains Unanswered
Carrick sacked, Fernandes rejects the contract, Pochettino signs a two-and-a-half-year deal. The Manchester United board is rearranging the seats; the structural problem stays exactly where it was.
On Wednesday morning, while Michael Carrick was running training in Manchester, club executives were signing someone else's name in Monaco. That scene — the coach sweating in the dressing room while the bosses decided his fate in Monaco — summed up in a single frame the structural ailment Manchester United have carried since 2013. The scoreline comes in the second sentence: Carrick won only three of 15 Premier League matches, leaving the team in the relegation zone.
But before we get to the numbers, let us slow down that ill-fated Aston Villa night. Going 2-0 down inside the first four minutes of a match that ended 4-4, entering the second half 4-2 behind and then salvaging a draw with a miraculous comeback — according to the figures in the package, it was a result that controversially stretched what xG would expect. A few days earlier there had been a similar rescue against Roma in the Champions League. The board read those two moments not as 'character' but as 'chaos'.
Mauricio Pochettino's arrival at Old Trafford on a two-and-a-half-year contract is the long-running interest finally taking concrete form. The club considered him in the summer of 2024, immediately after his departure from Chelsea; it was decided that the timing did not suit either side. Erik ten Hag, Ruben Amorim, Carrick — and now Pochettino. According to reports, this is the eighth permanent appointment since Ferguson's retirement in 2013.
Pochettino's first match is against Liverpool at Anfield on 22 November. The Argentina-born coach, known for his experience at Tottenham, Chelsea and Paris Saint-Germain, is currently in charge of the US national team's matches against Haiti on Saturday and Wednesday. That detail may look small, but it says this about a man: he is someone who completes his commitments.
On the other hand, the Bruno Fernandes issue continues to sit in the shadow of this appointment. The 32-year-old captain was named PFA Player of the Year last season after breaking a Premier League record with 21 assists — and now he has rejected a second contract offer as well. His current contract expires at the end of the season; the club holds a one-year option and could also block Fernandes from speaking to foreign clubs in January. The Saudi league's considerable economic pull may once again begin to swirl around a name that drew Al Hilal's interest last year.
It needs to be said plainly: this decision is the product of the leadership headed by Omar Berrada and Jason Wilcox. The board believes the current squad is far better than the results. That belief is not wrong, but it is incomplete. Carrick last season won 12 of 17 matches, taking the team to third place and the Champions League, and even rose to a nomination for manager of the season. This season, only three wins in 15 matches. It is not squad quality but the lack of structural clarity that has kept United turning in the same place for twelve years.
Jonny Evans, Jonathan Woodgate, Steve Holland, Travis Binnion and goalkeeping coach Craig Mawson have also left the club. It is easy to say that history repeats itself. But the pattern says this: at Old Trafford the problem is not who the head coach is, but who sacks him, when and where.