This story is currently available in англійська only — a translation isn't ready yet.
Sotheby's pressed to halt $180m Van Gogh sale over Nazi-era claim
Descendants of the Bermann Fischer publishing family say the 1890 work was sold in Amsterdam in 1936 under persecution; Sotheby's says its research found no coercion.
ℹ️ Озвучка браузером · студійний голос ШІ незабаром

Sotheby's has been asked to suspend Thursday's sale in New York of Vincent van Gogh's 'Châtaigniers en fleurs', estimated at 180 million dollars, by descendants of the German publishing family that once owned it. The claimants, relatives of the Bermann Fischer family now living in the United States, argue the painting was sold in Amsterdam in 1936 under the pressure of Nazi persecution.
Their lawyer Gunnar Schnabel, who specialises in Nazi-looted art cases, set out the demand in a letter to Sotheby's restitution department. He asks the auction house to prove the work was sold at market price at the time, regardless of persecution.
Samuel Fischer, founder of the S. Fischer Verlag, bought the painting in 1909 at a gallery in Paris and deposited it with the art dealer Walter Feilchenfeldt in 1932 or 1933. It was shown in Amsterdam in 1933 and at the Kunsthalle Bern in 1934. When Fischer died in 1934, his daughter Brigitte and her husband Gottfried Bermann Fischer inherited it. In 1935 the couple fled, paying the 'Reichsfluchtsteuer', via Vienna and Stockholm to the United States. Months later Feilchenfeldt sold the picture in Amsterdam to the collectors Henriette and Marcel Kapferer. It changed hands four more times in the following decades.
Schnabel argues that after the Second World War the family's ownership of the publishing house, by then divided, was restored, but that Bermann Fischer neither sought nor obtained restitution of paintings sold during the Nazi period in Amsterdam. He cites the absence of a legal basis for compensating art sales in countries that were not under Nazi rule when the transaction took place, as with the Netherlands in 1936.
Sotheby's says its 'extensive research' had not established 'that the painting was sold under duress'. The house said it wants 'a constructive dialogue with the family' and a 'solution satisfactory to both sides'. The Dutch Restitution Commission and the country's heritage agency assess sales between 1933 and May 1940 case by case, recommending return where a sale is shown to have been persecution-related and no regular market value obtained.
California strengthened claims to property taken from politically persecuted people, and a rewritten federal statute is meant to stop restitution cases failing on timing or technical objections. The Kunstmuseum Bern restituted an Alfred Sisley in 2025 to heirs of the Breslau collector Carl Sachs, who sold it in 1940 after fleeing to Switzerland. A Paris court ordered the return of a Camille Pissarro that Sotheby's had auctioned in London for 1.2 million pounds, to the heirs of a Jewish collector dispossessed during the Nazi occupation of France.
The painting comes to auction after half a century in private hands, from the collection of the Argentinian Nelly Arrieta de Blaquier. A guarantee by the auction house to the sellers underpins the estimate; at that price it would be the most expensive Van Gogh ever sold at auction.
Sources — how we know this
4 independent sources corroborated this
- PrimaryFrankfurter Allgemeine
- CorroboratingBBC World News
- CorroboratingAsharq Al-Awsat (EN)
- CorroboratingDutchNews