EFF and ACLU ask Sixth Circuit to require a warrant for plate-reader searches
The amicus brief in United States v. Sturdivant says searching Flock and ELSAG databases for a driver's past movements is a Fourth Amendment search.

EFF and the ACLU filed an amicus brief in the Sixth Circuit court of appeals in United States v. Sturdivant, a case in which police tracked a suspect's movements using automated license plate reader data without a warrant. The brief argues that ALPR searches require a warrant.
It details a vast, interconnected network of ALPRs that constantly track drivers around the country, and argues that this tracking is a "search" under the meaning of the Fourth Amendment.
Sturdivant involves a series of robberies in and around Cleveland, Ohio. Using surveillance camera footage, police identified the make, model and color of the robber's car, but they did not know its license plate number. Officers then ran an open-ended search of two ALPR databases, Flock and ELSAG, and learned that a car belonging to the defendant had been tracked near the sites of the robberies, eventually leading to his arrest.
Faced with a motion to suppress the ALPR evidence, the district court held that Mr. Sturdivant had no reasonable expectation of privacy in his license plate number because it could be observed by members of the public, and that he therefore had no Fourth Amendment interest in not having his car tracked in public places.
EFF argues that ALPRs are not comparable to observing an individual license plate on a passing car. The brief says the systems give law enforcement "a virtual time machine to view suspects', or anyone else's, past movements" with the click of a button.
Last month a federal district court agreed and held that ALPRs are a "form of indiscriminate mass surveillance" that can violate the Fourth Amendment. EFF has also challenged ALPR use in San Jose, California, and Wisconsin.
EFF said it hopes the Sixth Circuit will reverse the lower court in this case and hold that ALPR searches require a warrant.
Sources — how we know this
- PrimaryHacker News Front Page