Five EU states plan Rwanda deportations for rejected asylum seekers
Alexander Dobrindt announced the plan with four EU counterparts; critics say 20 million euros for about 40 places is exorbitant.

Germany, Austria, Denmark, the Netherlands and Greece plan to deport rejected asylum seekers to Rwanda, Interior Minister Alexander Dobrindt announced on Monday with his four counterparts — a step migration expert Gerald Knaus casts as the opening move in a deeper change of EU migration policy.
Sebastian Fiedler, interior policy spokesman for the Social Democrats in the Bundestag, called the cost exorbitant: 20 million euros for "about 40 places". Dobrindt must set out the ratio of effort to benefit, he said.
Knaus argues the plan should be judged in a larger frame. The participating governments want to show that deportations to Rwanda hold up before European courts, he said. If they do, the model could open the way to safe third-country schemes in which asylum procedures themselves are handled outside the EU. "The goal must be to make irregular migration pointless," he said.
No agreement yet sets out the details or a timetable. Experts expect those by early 2027, with first deportations possible during the coming year. Deportations of migrants without a right to stay often fail because their countries of origin do not cooperate; the Rwanda arrangement would remove that dependence.
Whether the model survives depends on judges. The European Court of Justice would have to find it compatible with human rights law and the Geneva Refugee Convention, including whether deported asylum seekers' fundamental rights are secured in Rwanda — a country governed autocratically for decades by President Paul Kagame, where opponents and journalists are persecuted. Knaus argues rights could be secured because Rwanda wants to establish itself as a reliable partner for the EU. Judges must also weigh the removal of the so-called connection element from EU law, which asked whether an asylum seeker has a link to the country receiving them.
Eurostat data show fewer than a third of migrants ordered to leave were deported last year. Knaus points to the EU-Turkey agreement of 18 March 2016, which he helped design and after which arrivals fell sharply.
Greece has used its own method since February: anyone denied asylum must leave within two weeks or face up to five years in a closed facility, with electronic ankle tags to stop people absconding. "Either they go back to their home countries or they go to prison," Migration Minister Thanos Plevris told parliament in June. Italy under Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni opened two migration centres in Albania, the first such centres outside the EU, though implementation ran into trouble because Italy moved ahead of EU legislation.
Sources — how we know this
7 independent sources corroborated this
- PrimaryHandelsblatt
- CorroboratingAl Jazeera English
- CorroboratingEgypt Independent
- CorroboratingBBC World News
- CorroboratingFinancial Times — UK
- CorroboratingThe National (UAE)
- CorroboratingLe Monde in English