HMRC to gain powers over bereaved families' tax records and AI chatbot histories
Budget Resolutions added to the Finance Bill would let HMRC demand information about the dead without time limit and treat unintentional errors as deliberate.

HMRC is to gain sweeping new powers to demand information about deceased taxpayers without a time limit, inspect records of taxpayers' conversations with AI chatbots, and treat unintentional errors on old returns as "deliberate", under Budget Resolutions added to the Finance Bill that survived their first reading on 3 November.
The measures sit alongside tax rises announced by Chancellor John Healey at the despatch box, including hikes to savings, property and income tax. HMRC estimates the tax gap cost the Treasury nearly £60bn in lost tax receipts during the 2024/25 financial year. Healey said restoring fiscal discipline was his "first commitment as Chancellor", including "raising revenue from those who can afford to pay". Labour's manifesto prevents hikes to income tax, VAT and employee national insurance, so the government is leaning on compliance and greater enforcement powers for HMRC to raise revenue.
From April 2028 a statutory "Duty to Correct" regime will legally require taxpayers to rectify mistakes on old tax returns once they become aware of them. Currently a mistake discovered after filing is treated as "careless", carrying a lower penalty of up to 30 per cent of the unpaid tax over six years. Under the new regime an inaccuracy – even if unintentional – will be branded "deliberate", the highest penalty tier, carrying a fine of up to 100 per cent and a scrutiny period of 20 years. Tax barristers have criticised the lack of a minimum threshold and the two-decade window, which clashes with statutory record-keeping rules requiring the self-employed to keep records for five to six years. Fiona Fernie, partner at Blick Rothenberg, said: "This legislation needs clearer safeguards and a finite time limit for making corrections."
HMRC can currently demand information from the families of deceased taxpayers for up to four years after their death if it suspects they have paid the wrong amount of tax, covering inheritance tax, capital gains tax and income tax. The proposals grant the right to demand information about the dead for an unlimited period, and the right to gather evidence for existing tax investigations that reach back up to 20 years. Draft legislation states HMRC will have to apply to a tax tribunal to send an information demand more than four years after death, but will not be required to inform the executors of the estate, or the family, until after the tribunal has made a decision.
The definition of digital "records" will be expanded to allow access to "relevant" digital records, which may include AI chatbots, and third parties including software providers will be required to give HMRC people's tax information if they hold it. Praveen Gupta, head of tax at accountancy and advisory firm Azets, said conversations between a taxpayer and their adviser are confidential and "AI conversations should be treated in the same way". Matthew Greene, partner at Stewarts, said access to AI chat histories "could help uncover tax irregularities" but "also risks dragging innocent taxpayers into unnecessary investigations".
An HMRC spokesperson said: "We know most of our customers act in good faith" and that they want to get their tax right. The spokesperson said taxpayers will not be penalised for innocent mistakes, and that deliberate penalty charges only arise where taxpayers fail to take reasonable steps to correct an inaccuracy they were already aware of. A government spokesperson said: "This does not mean new powers and will not affect the vast majority of taxpayers."
Sources — how we know this
- PrimaryCity AM