NoorSadaNoorSada
BREAKINGJudiciaryDeveloping✓ 13 sources

Judge may set new trial date for Lindsay Clancy in Plymouth Superior Court

A hearing is set for 10 a.m. Monday in Plymouth Superior Court, after Judge William Sullivan declared a mistrial on Sept. 2 when jurors deadlocked 11-1.

Speed:

DR
Daniel Reyes
· 2 min read
Lindsay Clancy in a gray zip-up sweater looks at the camera · Photo: Plymouth Superior Court / Public domain

A Massachusetts judge could set a tentative start date for a second murder trial for Lindsay Clancy at a hearing scheduled for 10 a.m. Monday in Plymouth Superior Court.

Prosecutors have not yet said whether they plan to retry Ms. Clancy on first-degree murder charges, lesser charges or at all. Judge William Sullivan indicated at a hearing earlier this month that he intends to choose a tentative start date for a second trial.

Jurors at Ms. Clancy's first trial were unable to break their 11-1 deadlock after nearly 40 hours of deliberations, and the judge declared a mistrial on Sept. 2. If prosecutors reduce the charges to second-degree murder or manslaughter, Ms. Clancy could avoid a second jury trial and have her fate decided by a judge instead.

Judge Sullivan dismissed several motions by Ms. Clancy's lawyers last week, including one that argued for the dismissal of the charges. Her lawyers have asserted that any retrial would constitute double jeopardy because the mistrial could have been avoided if the judge had dug deeper into the conduct of the lone juror who voted to convict. The defense team said in its motion that if the judge had investigated further, he might have found grounds for dismissing that juror and replacing him with an alternate.

In his ruling, Judge Sullivan found that such an inquiry would have been "impermissibly coercive," given the lack of evidence that the juror had done anything wrong. Judge Sullivan also dismissed a defense motion arguing for further investigation of the holdout juror.

Kevin Reddington, the lawyer for Ms. Clancy, had argued that the juror had failed to disclose information about his own past criminal charges. Heather O'Connor, a lawyer for the juror, has said that he "believed he was truthful" on the juror questionnaire that he filled out during the jury selection process last summer.

Ms. Clancy, 36, has remained in custody at a state hospital since the mistrial. Her trial was televised and lasted for six weeks. Mr. Reddington had argued during the trial that she was not criminally responsible for killing Cora, 5; Dawson, 3; and Callan, 8 months, because she was experiencing severe postpartum mental illness and hallucinated a voice that ordered her to kill them and herself. After strangling her children, Ms. Clancy cut her wrists and throat and jumped from a window, sustaining spinal injuries that left her paralyzed.

The online furor around the case, and the intense scrutiny and criticism of the jurors after the mistrial, have raised concerns about the prospect of seating another jury for a second trial. At the hearing on Nov. 2, Mr. Reddington expressed impatience with prosecutors and said: "The ball is in Mr. Cruz's court," referring to Timothy Cruz, the Plymouth district attorney, who has pledged to continue seeking justice for the Clancy children.

Sources — how we know this

13 independent sources corroborated this

#Judiciary○ ...