NoorSadaNoorSada
Sports

Pochettino's Real Battle: Head Coach or Figurehead?

The 54-year-old Argentine signed a contract until 2029, but the real question is this: does he have a say in the transfer file, or will the board again chart its own course?

Speed:

ℹ️ Browser-based reading · AI studio voice coming soon

Omar Farouk
· 2 min read
Map: Saudi Arabia · Photo: NoorSada · Natural Earth

Two days ago in this column I wrote that Pochettino had set foot in Old Trafford and said 'the real question is still unanswered.' Today I have to ask that question a little more clearly — because the answer now goes far beyond press conference rhetoric.

Pochettino takes over Manchester United after Michael Carrick. He has a contract running to the summer of 2029; the figure the club paid to terminate his contract in the US is 7.4 million pounds. What he found in front of him is a squad that has produced one of the worst 10-match openings in Premier League history and is stuck in the relegation zone.

That much was already known. The real issue is this: who has the final say?

Look at the INEOS era — Omar Berrada was brought in from Manchester City, Jason Wilcox was brought in from Southampton as manager, Dan Ashworth was prised away from Newcastle and shown the door within five months after a 200 million pound squad spend. This sequence shows that grand titles mean nothing on the pitch. Ashworth is gone; so whose hands is transfer policy left in?

A seasoned commentator is right to ask whether control of the transfer window lies with Pochettino. What is being said is this: Pochettino needs urgent reinforcement in the defensive line. The squad from the Carrick era is structurally alien to the high-pressing system he wants to build. Pochettino, who laid the first stones with a 4-2-3-1 at Southampton and built an identity on top of those stones at Spurs, wants to work not with the material he has but with the material he wants to buy; this is a tendency he has shown in every period.

But now there are too many hands at the table. There is Berrada, there is Wilcox, there is Sir Jim Ratcliffe. The Ashworth story has already proved to us that these hands do not move in harmony with one another.

Look at the emotional press conference: Pochettino could not hold back his tears as he left the US national team. 'One of the hardest decisions of my career,' he said, 'but to make your dreams come true you have to be professional.' The weight of this confession does not come from nostalgia alone — those tears are also a sign of awareness. Leaving a contract that runs to the summer of 2029 shows that he truly believes in something big. Or that he was truly promised something big.

My guess is this: the United that takes the field against Liverpool on 22 November will be measured not by how it plays but by whose players it takes the field with. Pochettino could not fully hold the transfer file in his own hands at Tottenham or PSG either. There too he was left alone at times. Now Old Trafford is a bigger stage — but the size of the stage does not shrink the power struggle behind the curtain.

The first real test is not at Anfield — the first real test lies in whose desk the signature comes from when the winter transfer window opens.

#Sports○ ...