Victims' group sues Newsom over plan to commute all 548 California death sentences
The Criminal Justice Legal Foundation asks the California Supreme Court to block the mass commutation and review each of the state's 548 death sentences individually.

California prosecutors and the families of murder victims sued Gov. Gavin Newsom on Monday over his move to commute all death sentences in the state, asking the California Supreme Court to block the mass commutation and allow time for each of the state's 548 death sentences to be reviewed individually.
The suit was filed by the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation, a nonprofit group focused on victims' rights. It alleges Newsom violated laws requiring that prosecutors and victims' survivors have input on whether a prisoner's sentence should be reduced. The plaintiffs also argue that errors in some inmates' criminal records raise questions about whether the governor has the legal authority to reduce certain sentences.
Under California law, a governor may unilaterally commute the sentence of a prisoner convicted of a felony in a single case. To reduce the sentences of inmates with convictions in multiple felony cases, the governor must seek approval from the state Supreme Court. Newsom has sent a list of 382 prisoners with multiple convictions to the court; the rest of the death sentences were for prisoners convicted in single cases, which he says allows him to act alone.
The lawsuit contends that some prisoners on Newsom's single-conviction list may actually have more felony convictions and cannot have their sentences reduced without court approval. It asks the court to stop the governor from granting clemency until the cases are vetted.
"A mass clemency is inconsistent with a scheme designed to create a public process," the lawsuit says.
Earlier this month, Newsom said he felt a moral obligation to convert all death sentences to life in prison, though he acknowledged the decision would "anger and hurt some Californians." In a letter announcing the move, he wrote that he was acting on his conviction that "we are stronger as a society when we reject state-sanctioned killing."
Everyone on California's death row has been convicted of murder. Surviving family members of murder victims held dueling news conferences last week: one group backed the commutations and urged the court to move swiftly, while the other said Newsom had disrespected them and reopened old wounds.
Associations representing district attorneys, police officers and crime survivors joined the suit, arguing that one person should not be able to overrule the judgment of thousands of jurors and hundreds of judges at once. Other lawyers have argued the governor has broad authority to grant clemency.
The court has asked that opinions on the commutation request be filed by Nov. 24 and must decide before Newsom leaves office on Jan. 4. It is the first time the California Supreme Court has been asked to approve hundreds of commutations at once based on a governor's moral opposition to capital punishment.
Sources — how we know this
2 independent sources corroborated this
- PrimaryThe New York Times — U.S.
- CorroboratingNBC News